MANN vs. WORLD
The Continuing Saga of Eli's Swan Song
After Two Games Giants Announce Plan to Start Daniel Jones in Week Three
- Two Games: 56 attempts/89 completions (63%) for 556 yards; two touchdowns; one INT; two sacks, 10 QB hits.
Cut the music!
After just two verses, Eli's swan song is over.
Manning is not the sole reason, or even a top three reason, why the 2018 Giants post a 3-13 record. Nor is he a primary reason why the Giants are 47-67 over the last seven seasons. They're certainly not off to an 0-2 start this season on account of Eli. For that you must start with a novice defense which has so far allowed 60-plus points through two games with no hope of improvement in the foreseeable future. Of course there's much more to this burgeoning nightmare. But I digress ...
Eli is the last vestige of Ernie Accorsi's legacy as general manager of the New York Giants. It is Accorsi who builds a Super Bowl contender with Eli being the final piece of the puzzle. However those Giants first need to wait out Eli's maturation process. By 2007 Eli Manning transforms before our very eyes into Mr. Freeze at Green Bay and goes on to win MVP of Super Bowl XLII. By 2011 the Giants are squeezing the last bit of goodness out of Accorsi's creation en route to winning Super Bowl XLVI. Eli Manning is again named game MVP.
In the seasons following 2011 the shelf life of an elite defense, a record setting offensive line, and once formidable running game all expire. But because Eli was the last piece of the puzzle, he is also the last to remain. In the meantime, Jerry Reese presides over the complete and utter deterioration of the New York Giants. His drafting over his last five seasons as general manager bear no fruit, thus fostering a failed if not ruinous over reliance on free agency. The impact on the field is self evident: sub par records.
Former offensive coordinator Kevin Gilbride together with his friend and Giants head coach Tom Coughlin are as aggressive as they come. When the Giants still field a competent offensive line and formidable running game, Gilbride maintains effective balance between rushing and passing. But when it comes to passing, the triumvirate of Gilbride, Coach Coughlin, and Eli Manning, are all about high risk and high reward. As a result they routinely lead the league in most yards attempted per pass! That partly explains why Eli appears prone to throwing interceptions. But Coughlin effectively signs off on each and every INT. They just didn't care. However as the talent level deteriorates along the offensive line and the running game comes to a halt, Gilbride becomes Jerry Reese's first scapegoat. The continuing deterioration of talent over the next two seasons likewise causes Tom Coughlin into coaching more desperately. He then becomes Jerry Reese scapegoat number two.
In truth, Gilbride, Coughlin, or even Ben McAdoo, were never the problem, per se. The primary factor causing the Giants spiraling into irrelevance is John Mara's unyielding support for Jerry Reese.
Sure, Eli deserves his fair share of blame. His performance can be ponderous at times. Everyone deserves their fair share for this mess. Some just deserve more than others.
Upon accepting positions with the Giants Dave Gettleman and Pat Shurmur know they are being tasked with putting Eli out to pasture. Indeed, an unenviable position to be in. Yet the process continues to wreak of indecisiveness and lack of conviction. I'm not sure what they're thinking. But it needs to stop. Because the less sense this makes the more I'm inclined to believe John Mara still has his fingerprints all over this. And why would that be? Because he completely botches Eli's benching in favor of Geno Smith. What a slap in the face, made worse by how the front office continues mishandling the aftermath. Moreover because I believe Archie Manning commands Mara's respect and attention. And if I'm Archie, I'm on the phone to John Mara blaming him, Jerry Reese, and Dave Gettleman, for essentially ruining the second half of his son's career.
It appears push has finally come to shove. Eli is facing one of three choices: retire a Giant; waive his no trade clause; or stay and tutor Daniel Jones. Concerned parties had better reserve a large conference room because I'm sure John Mara, Dave Gettleman, Pat Shurmur, Eli Manning, his agent, and Archie Manning, will all have something to say about this.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Say what you feel. The worse comment you can make is the one you do not make.