From the desk of: DO IT FOR THE DUKE
NEW YORK GIANTS FOOTBALL - Don't Let Big Blue Fool You. The Running Game Didn't Improve Much.
It's always something. If it's not one thing, it's another. When Eli Manning was a wee QB still wet behind the ears, he was protected by the best offensive line in football, and supplemented by the league's number one running game. Two Super Bowls later, now that Eli is the Mann he plays behind an offensive line that is painstakingly undergoing an overhaul, as well as getting little to no help from a largely non existent running game.
Don't let them fool you. The Giants protected Eli well enough. They also improved upon their dreadful 2011 season when they ranked dead last in rushing. They upped their ranking to 14th in the NFL running the ball this season. But that could unfortunately make it easy to overlook their real dilemma. Not only have they have lost their ability to dominate the clock utilizing the run, worse, after Andre Brown went down Big Blue became exceptionally futile in short yardage situations. Far too often, the Giants settled for field goals because they puttered in the red zone. If they failed to gain short yardage, then naturally they failed to gain first downs.
Once again Ahmad Bradshaw showed he is a compromised player. Yet he still posted another 1,000 yard season. But how much longer can he last before his lower appendages break apart? Does Jerry Reese plan on bringing Andre Brown back? Does he even bring Bradshaw back? Will Coach Coughlin and the Giants feature David Wilson more often in the backfield next season? Has David Wilson sufficiently learned how to pick up a blitz yet? The Giants have three uncertain scenarios in their backfield. For two backs at least, the future seems unclear. However, I think it is unlikely Jerry Reese uses a top two pick on a running back in the next draft. So perhaps David Wilson's starting time will be born of necessity.
Up front, the biggest question facing the Offensive Line is what to do about David Diehl. Let's face it, he's fading fast. He is clearly not coming off a good, or healthy, two year stretch. The time has come to replace him, or, move him back to Guard again, which is where he came from. Tackle is just not his forte. Although he was far from being a liability, David Diehl just wasn't effective enough. Sean Locklear was clearly the better Tackle when given playing time. But as luck would have it, Locklear was felled by a season ending knee injury.
At Right Guard, Chris Snee had himself another good season, but continues to pay a high physical toll. His time is growing shorter. And at Center, I still maintain David Baas is undersized. The left side of the line was manned by Will Beatty and Kevin Boothe. Individually, I do not have much to gripe about. But collectively, this line has become very average. Will Beatty is a pending free agent.
If I had my way, Jerry Reese would be spending a high draft pick on a Center or Tackle. The Giants need a stud on the line. And in the mean time, hand the starting Right Tackle position to Sean Locklear assuming he is okay to return. Then relegate David Diehl to back up Guard. Re-signing Will Beatty almost seems necessary right now. The Giants lack depth. So keep enough money within the cap and see which free agent linemen might possibly fit in. If Locklear doesn't heal up, the Giants will need to find someone fast.
Mike.BTB
Showing posts with label Sean Locklear. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sean Locklear. Show all posts
Wednesday, January 16, 2013
Wednesday, December 05, 2012
New York Giants: Injuries Causing Problems At Right Tackle
From the desk of: DO IT FOR THE DUKE
NEW YORK GIANTS FOOTBALL: Offensive Line Depth Is Suddenly A Big Problem.
NEW YORK GIANTS FOOTBALL: Offensive Line Depth Is Suddenly A Big Problem.
Hello again folks. My post-Hurricane Sandy schedule is finally starting to loosen up. So allow me a post or two in order to re-establish a flow. The last time I posted anything about the Giants was just prior to the Bengals game. Obviously many things have transpired between now and then. And aside from the Packers game, I'm kind of glad I was unable to watch the other contests, although the radio did a fine job of raising my blood pressure all the same. I'm not going to waste time rehashing stuff. Let's just move this along..., shall we?
* * * *
The Giants now have a huge problem at Right Tackle. Sean Locklear will be out for the rest of the season with an injured knee suffered Monday night against the Redskins. He didn't exactly have his best game Monday. In fact, it was probably his worst game. But he was having a fine season substituting for David Diehl. And therein lies the rub. Most recently, Diehl has been sidelined by a stinger to his neck and shoulder.
Sean Locklear has done his part to improve the Giants running game somewhat over last season. And his pass protection has been stellar. The nine year pro definitely provided a noticeable difference on the right side this year. David Diehl should be able to finish out the season. But moving forward, the Giants' offensive line depth will be severely tested. Second year Jim Cordle is more of an interior lineman. That leaves second year Tackle James Brewer next on the pecking order. Remember Mitch Petrus? Well, Coach Coughlin would rather not. He never found favor with Mitch. But the Giants could use him right about now.
It is becoming more evident by the week, this may very well be David Diehl's last season. His performance has not been up to normal David Diehl standards these last two seasons. I have a strong sense Jerry Reese will make replacing Diehl an off season priority. David Diehl will then join Shaun O'Hara, Rich Seubert, and Kareem McKenzie as former Giants. That would leave Chris Snee as the lone remaining member of the Giants former record setting offensive line.
MONDAY FINAL:
GIANTS 16
Redskins 17
I'm not going to get bent all out of shape over Monday night's loss. There is no doubt the offense has red-zone issues. But you still have to like the way the Giants can move the ball. Even though it has been a season long issue, going from three point to six point drives I feel is only an adjustment or two away.
The Giants only surrendered seventeen points, and six of those came on RGIII's freak TD fumble. Big Blue also drew penalties at an uncharacteristically high rate, and at the worst possible times. Then quite obviously, if Lawrence Tynes nails that field goal, the Giants win. So I take the loss in stride.
Mike.BTB
Sunday, November 11, 2012
New York Giants: Rushing To Conclusions?
From the desk of: Do It For The Duke - My Phone Version
NEW YORK GIANTS: I Ask Again, Is The Offensive Line Better Without David Diehl?
I touched upon this earlier in the season, and now I feel compelled to revisit the issue. There is a building case that perhaps suggests the Offensive Line is better without David Diehl.
With David Diehl out and Sean Locklear in, the Giants were rushing for 100 yards per game. Prior to Diehl getting hurt after week two, the G-Men failed to gain 100 yards against the Cowboys and Tampa Bay. When Diehl went down and Sean Locklear stepped in, the Giants rushed for over 100 yards in three consecutive games, highlighted by Ahmad Bradshaw's 200 yard game against Cleveland. With Diehl back in the line-up the running game has regressed again with three consecutive poor efforts against the Skins, Cowboys II, and last week against the Steelers.
I do not question the results based on this season alone. Last year with David Diehl playing Left Tackle, over the course of the season the Giants did their best running to the right side behind Kareem McKenzie and Chris Snee. When they ran left behind Diehl and Kevin Boothe, the effort lacked even similar results.
Up the middle, Chris Snee is still playing like Chris Snee. David Baas and Kevin Boothe have become a nice combo. There are no real issues with Will Beatty to speak of. So that leaves Right Tackle. With Sean Locklear in, the Giants have run to one result. With Diehl in, the Giants have rushed for another.
This week, my issue is somewhat moot if Chris Snee does not play. In that case, Diehl will shift to Guard, and Locklear will play Tackle. I will however be paying close attention to how the Giants manage running outside Right Tackle, and how they fare between Tackle and Guard.
P.S. This, like many posts in my immediate future are being written on the fly. So please be patient during the next few weeks. Work, and the continuing efforts to recover from Sandy currently dominate my time. And that means no spell check either. So deal with it.
Thanks,
Mike.BTB
NEW YORK GIANTS: I Ask Again, Is The Offensive Line Better Without David Diehl?
I touched upon this earlier in the season, and now I feel compelled to revisit the issue. There is a building case that perhaps suggests the Offensive Line is better without David Diehl.
With David Diehl out and Sean Locklear in, the Giants were rushing for 100 yards per game. Prior to Diehl getting hurt after week two, the G-Men failed to gain 100 yards against the Cowboys and Tampa Bay. When Diehl went down and Sean Locklear stepped in, the Giants rushed for over 100 yards in three consecutive games, highlighted by Ahmad Bradshaw's 200 yard game against Cleveland. With Diehl back in the line-up the running game has regressed again with three consecutive poor efforts against the Skins, Cowboys II, and last week against the Steelers.
I do not question the results based on this season alone. Last year with David Diehl playing Left Tackle, over the course of the season the Giants did their best running to the right side behind Kareem McKenzie and Chris Snee. When they ran left behind Diehl and Kevin Boothe, the effort lacked even similar results.
Up the middle, Chris Snee is still playing like Chris Snee. David Baas and Kevin Boothe have become a nice combo. There are no real issues with Will Beatty to speak of. So that leaves Right Tackle. With Sean Locklear in, the Giants have run to one result. With Diehl in, the Giants have rushed for another.
This week, my issue is somewhat moot if Chris Snee does not play. In that case, Diehl will shift to Guard, and Locklear will play Tackle. I will however be paying close attention to how the Giants manage running outside Right Tackle, and how they fare between Tackle and Guard.
P.S. This, like many posts in my immediate future are being written on the fly. So please be patient during the next few weeks. Work, and the continuing efforts to recover from Sandy currently dominate my time. And that means no spell check either. So deal with it.
Thanks,
Mike.BTB
Saturday, October 20, 2012
New York Giants: Is Offensive Line Better Without David Diehl?
From the desk of: DO IT FOR THE DUKE
While Big Blue sports an overall 4-2 record this season, they are 0-2 within the division. The Giants will have to wait for later in the season to square up with Philly. Next week, they'll get their chance to even up against the Cowboys in Dallas. First, there is the matter of RG3 and the Redskins. If you do not remember, Washington swept the Giants last year and damn nearly pulled the rug out from under their season. This year, the Redskins along with Philly both sport 3-3 records. The Giants can either win this week and next, and by virtue of righting some wrongs, take a mid-season strangle hold on the division. Or, they can lose to the Skins again, and make things very complicated for themselves. For if you're a Giants fan, you know success makes the team break out in a rash. For what ever reason, they do not handle prosperity very well. Making things difficult has become a way of life around here.
The biggest question I have heading into Sunday is not how the Giants plan on stopping RG3. Instead, I'm curious to see if Kevin Gilbride will open the game with hey makers down field, or try and establish the run early. Based on the last few games, the running game has been working very well behind good blocking by the offensive line. Last week for the first time this season, the Giants ran the ball more times than Eli passed. It would stand to reason Coach Gilbride would continue letting his offensive line build confidence and momentum.
This is precisely why I think Kevin Gilbride is going deep, and going deep often. Based on the division scenario described above, and because the Giants did indeed lose twice to Washington last season, and because Kevin Gilbride smells win number five like blood in the water, he will be going for the kill early. Quick points and an early lead means the defensive line can then tee-off on RG3 and all that stuff he does. Then, the Giants can turn to the run and play ball possession. Those would be two ways to minimize Washington's offense. Coach Fewell can take care of the rest.
Of course, I could be wrong.
There is no question Ahmad Bradshaw is tough, and plays hurt. He's had bad feet for years. Ahmad did not practice Friday, and is listed as questionable for Sunday, which means he will most likely play. But perhaps David Wilson should finally get a majority of snaps this week, not necessarily because Bradshaw is a little banged up, but because Wilson has worked hard to earn a shot. And then, yea, Ahmad could use the break. Besides, Wilson's type of speed may be just what the doctor ordered against Washington. Forget what he has done on kick returns. Since his infamous fumble in Week One, David Wilson is averaging over five yards per carry rushing the ball. In the last two weeks he has gained seventy nine yards on seven carries.
Can it be the offensive line is better without David Diehl? I'm not trying to slight him or anything. Consider the Giants allowed three sacks to (Dallas) Demarcus Ware in Week One, David Diehl went down in Week Two, they allowed two more sacks against Carolina in Week Three, then nothing since. In Week One, the Giants rushed for eighty two yards. In Week Two, they rushed for ninety six yards. After David Diehl went down, the Giants broke 100 yards rushing three times, highlighted by Ahmad Bradshaw's 200 yard day against the Browns. In the last four games, the Giants have racked up 572 yards rushing. From left to right, Will Beatty, Kevin Boothe, David Baas, Chris Snee, and Sean Locklear have flat out been getting the job done. David Diehl does not appear to be resuming his starting role this week. He only saw light action against the Niners. But when he is healthy enough to start again, Big Blue has a Giant decision to make.
Mike.BTB
NEW YORK GIANTS FOOTBALL:
Big Blue Has A Giant Decision To Make On Offensive Line.
This Is A Good Week To Let David Wilson Be The Feature Back.
Kevin Gilbride Versus Redskins - Bombs Away?
Mission: Take Advantage Of Back-To-Back Division Games!
While Big Blue sports an overall 4-2 record this season, they are 0-2 within the division. The Giants will have to wait for later in the season to square up with Philly. Next week, they'll get their chance to even up against the Cowboys in Dallas. First, there is the matter of RG3 and the Redskins. If you do not remember, Washington swept the Giants last year and damn nearly pulled the rug out from under their season. This year, the Redskins along with Philly both sport 3-3 records. The Giants can either win this week and next, and by virtue of righting some wrongs, take a mid-season strangle hold on the division. Or, they can lose to the Skins again, and make things very complicated for themselves. For if you're a Giants fan, you know success makes the team break out in a rash. For what ever reason, they do not handle prosperity very well. Making things difficult has become a way of life around here.
The biggest question I have heading into Sunday is not how the Giants plan on stopping RG3. Instead, I'm curious to see if Kevin Gilbride will open the game with hey makers down field, or try and establish the run early. Based on the last few games, the running game has been working very well behind good blocking by the offensive line. Last week for the first time this season, the Giants ran the ball more times than Eli passed. It would stand to reason Coach Gilbride would continue letting his offensive line build confidence and momentum.
This is precisely why I think Kevin Gilbride is going deep, and going deep often. Based on the division scenario described above, and because the Giants did indeed lose twice to Washington last season, and because Kevin Gilbride smells win number five like blood in the water, he will be going for the kill early. Quick points and an early lead means the defensive line can then tee-off on RG3 and all that stuff he does. Then, the Giants can turn to the run and play ball possession. Those would be two ways to minimize Washington's offense. Coach Fewell can take care of the rest.
Of course, I could be wrong.
There is no question Ahmad Bradshaw is tough, and plays hurt. He's had bad feet for years. Ahmad did not practice Friday, and is listed as questionable for Sunday, which means he will most likely play. But perhaps David Wilson should finally get a majority of snaps this week, not necessarily because Bradshaw is a little banged up, but because Wilson has worked hard to earn a shot. And then, yea, Ahmad could use the break. Besides, Wilson's type of speed may be just what the doctor ordered against Washington. Forget what he has done on kick returns. Since his infamous fumble in Week One, David Wilson is averaging over five yards per carry rushing the ball. In the last two weeks he has gained seventy nine yards on seven carries.
Can it be the offensive line is better without David Diehl? I'm not trying to slight him or anything. Consider the Giants allowed three sacks to (Dallas) Demarcus Ware in Week One, David Diehl went down in Week Two, they allowed two more sacks against Carolina in Week Three, then nothing since. In Week One, the Giants rushed for eighty two yards. In Week Two, they rushed for ninety six yards. After David Diehl went down, the Giants broke 100 yards rushing three times, highlighted by Ahmad Bradshaw's 200 yard day against the Browns. In the last four games, the Giants have racked up 572 yards rushing. From left to right, Will Beatty, Kevin Boothe, David Baas, Chris Snee, and Sean Locklear have flat out been getting the job done. David Diehl does not appear to be resuming his starting role this week. He only saw light action against the Niners. But when he is healthy enough to start again, Big Blue has a Giant decision to make.
Mike.BTB
Tuesday, October 16, 2012
New York Giants: The Return Of Smash Mouth Football
From the desk of: DO IT FOR THE DUKE
Forget balance. Coach Kevin Gilbride is bucking trends. Against the Niners and for the first time all season, Coach decided to run the ball more times than he elected to pass. All praise him! Eli attempted twenty eight passes. Between Ahmad Bradshaw and David Wilson, the Giants rushed thirty four times and gained 151 yards.
It was the third time this season a Giants back rushed for over one hundred yards in a game. When Bradshaw missed Game Three with an injury, Andre Brown stepped in and rushed for 113 yards. Ahmad returned in Week Four and rushed thirteen times for thirty nine yards. Then came the explosion. In the last two weeks and behind fullback Henry Hynoski, Ahmad Bradshaw has gained 316 yards on the ground. Two hundred yards came against the Browns.
Last season's worst rushing offense now ranks 9th in the NFL. Minus Eli Manning scrambling around, the Giants have run the ball 153 times this season for a net 750 yards. That works out to 4.90 yards per attempt. Eli Manning has attempted 225 passes this season. So basically, Coach Gilbride is running the ball twice versus every three pass attempts.
David Wilson is also building momentum. Since suffering through a not so nifty start, and a stint in the dog house, the rookie has rebounded well, if not impressively. He has rushed the ball fifteen times this season for eighty eight yards, and one touchdown. Thanks to seventy nine yards on seven carries over the last two weeks, he is sporting a 5.87 yards per carry average so far this season.
His work on special teams has been exceptional. In six games and nineteen kick returns, David Wilson has amassed 540 yards. That's nearly a 28.5 yards per return average. Four times his game long return eclipsed thirty yards or better. He gained his season best against the 49ers with a sixty six yard return. Most impressive of all, he continues to blow by people with incredible bursts of speed.
As much speed as Wilson brings, and as elusive Ahmad Bradshaw is, none of this success could be possible without stellar play by the offensive line. They took a cue from their offensive coordinator and delivered upon the 49ers and old fashioned package of smash mouth football; Giants style. So far, only the Eagles have brought the running game to a halt back in Week Four. Whenever the Giants have rushed twenty five times or more in a game, they eclipsed one hundred yards and won. In the Giants two losses this season against Philly and Dallas, they only ran the ball nineteen times in each game and failed to gain ninety yards.
Despite Demarcus Ware and the Cowboys sacking Eli three times in the season opener, and two sacks surrendered to Carolina during a win, the offensive line has also pitched four shutouts. They haven't allowed a sack since Week Three.
Center Davis Baas is far removed from issues that affected his early to mid 2011 regular season. By December and certainly in the playoffs, Jerry Reese's free agent Line acquisition was proving his worth. This season with Chris Snee to his right, and Kevin Boothe to his left, the three have re-formed into a solid core. Ninth year Sean Locklear continued his surprisingly formidable play in place of David Diehl. Will Beatty continues to effectively protect Eli's blind side. Overall, the offensive line has every reason to feel highly confident about themselves.
This reconfigured line has pass protection seemingly down pat. If Coach Gilbride keeps dialing up the run, so far the trend says the more they run, the better they get.
Mike.BTB
NEW YORK GIANTS FOOTBALL: G-Men Find Their Smash Mouth In San Francisco. Offensive Line And
Running Game Rumble In The Bay Area.
OFFENSIVE COORDINATOR KEVIN GILBRIDE GOES OLD SCHOOL ON NINERS.
For the tongue lashing Jim Harbaugh directed Kevin Gilbride's way,
the Giants offensive coordinator got the final say.
And here is the lesson he planned for the 49er's coach...
Forget balance. Coach Kevin Gilbride is bucking trends. Against the Niners and for the first time all season, Coach decided to run the ball more times than he elected to pass. All praise him! Eli attempted twenty eight passes. Between Ahmad Bradshaw and David Wilson, the Giants rushed thirty four times and gained 151 yards.
It was the third time this season a Giants back rushed for over one hundred yards in a game. When Bradshaw missed Game Three with an injury, Andre Brown stepped in and rushed for 113 yards. Ahmad returned in Week Four and rushed thirteen times for thirty nine yards. Then came the explosion. In the last two weeks and behind fullback Henry Hynoski, Ahmad Bradshaw has gained 316 yards on the ground. Two hundred yards came against the Browns.
Last season's worst rushing offense now ranks 9th in the NFL. Minus Eli Manning scrambling around, the Giants have run the ball 153 times this season for a net 750 yards. That works out to 4.90 yards per attempt. Eli Manning has attempted 225 passes this season. So basically, Coach Gilbride is running the ball twice versus every three pass attempts.
David Wilson is also building momentum. Since suffering through a not so nifty start, and a stint in the dog house, the rookie has rebounded well, if not impressively. He has rushed the ball fifteen times this season for eighty eight yards, and one touchdown. Thanks to seventy nine yards on seven carries over the last two weeks, he is sporting a 5.87 yards per carry average so far this season.
His work on special teams has been exceptional. In six games and nineteen kick returns, David Wilson has amassed 540 yards. That's nearly a 28.5 yards per return average. Four times his game long return eclipsed thirty yards or better. He gained his season best against the 49ers with a sixty six yard return. Most impressive of all, he continues to blow by people with incredible bursts of speed.
As much speed as Wilson brings, and as elusive Ahmad Bradshaw is, none of this success could be possible without stellar play by the offensive line. They took a cue from their offensive coordinator and delivered upon the 49ers and old fashioned package of smash mouth football; Giants style. So far, only the Eagles have brought the running game to a halt back in Week Four. Whenever the Giants have rushed twenty five times or more in a game, they eclipsed one hundred yards and won. In the Giants two losses this season against Philly and Dallas, they only ran the ball nineteen times in each game and failed to gain ninety yards.
Despite Demarcus Ware and the Cowboys sacking Eli three times in the season opener, and two sacks surrendered to Carolina during a win, the offensive line has also pitched four shutouts. They haven't allowed a sack since Week Three.
Center Davis Baas is far removed from issues that affected his early to mid 2011 regular season. By December and certainly in the playoffs, Jerry Reese's free agent Line acquisition was proving his worth. This season with Chris Snee to his right, and Kevin Boothe to his left, the three have re-formed into a solid core. Ninth year Sean Locklear continued his surprisingly formidable play in place of David Diehl. Will Beatty continues to effectively protect Eli's blind side. Overall, the offensive line has every reason to feel highly confident about themselves.
This reconfigured line has pass protection seemingly down pat. If Coach Gilbride keeps dialing up the run, so far the trend says the more they run, the better they get.
Mike.BTB
Monday, October 01, 2012
New York Giants: Giants Loss Deeper Than Coulda, Woulda, Shoulda
From the desk of: DO IT FOR THE DUKE
First things first - The fact Lawrence Tynes missed what could have been the game winning field goal doesn't bother me in the slightest. He's got a good foot and is not why the Giants lost to the Eagles.
Next item - I do not mind that Kevin Gilbride and Coach Coughlin stayed ultra aggressive towards the end of Sunday night's game. There was a time (as recently as last season) when I would have ripped into the Offensive Coordinator. I guess two Super Bowls and Eli Manning have altered my thinking somewhat. Sure I would have ran the ball on second down with under 0:30 seconds left. But such as life. Let's not be hypocrites...okay? The old adage is you play for the win on the road, and for the tie at home. Could the coaches have considered a different way to matriculate the ball into field goal range? Yes, but again, I'm not concerned. Remember what they say about hindsight and apply it here.
Third on my list - I do not mind Eli's earlier interception in the end zone. Although that was perhaps one of the worse he has ever thrown. The fact is, offensively, Eli and whatever receivers on the field at any given time are the only components functioning well. With regards to Eli heroics, this is just the way this game played out. We fans can do a better job tempering ourselves when we start demanding perfection.
If Eli is indeed functioning well, let's give the Offensive Line some credit before I start a different tact. The Offensive Line has indeed provided Eli enough time to throw the ball. Eli suffered no sacks Sunday evening. They got help blocking from Martellus Bennett and Ahmad Bradshaw. But through a quarter season thus far, the group has pass protected well with or without David Diehl in the line-up.
Here is where I am concerned. First, I do not mind Aaron Brown only rushed the ball four times considering he was coming off two very productive weeks leading into Sunday. While Eli suffered no sacks Sunday evening, the O-Line created no holes to run through. The Giants rushed for a pathetic fifty seven yards. Low production out of the backfield is more than just a pattern. That concerns me. And that's why I give the way Sunday night's game ended, a pass.
Lastly, I was even more perturbed by costly holding penalties committed by the Offensive Line; i.e. - Will Beatty and Sean Locklear in particular.
If a team runs the ball well, and defends against the run well, that team will win a preponderance of their games. There in lies the reason why the Giants lost. Against the Eagles, they did neither well. Sunday night's contest was one of those very winnable games the Giants let slip by. But make no mistake, this game wasn't lost because Tynes missed the last second field goal, or Eli's INT in the end zone, or the Giants inability to run the ball. The Giants lost that game because they couldn't for the life of them stop Philadelphia's running game. All told, the Eagles gained 191 yards rushing. Michael Vick sprung free for forty nine yards on six carries. And LeSean McCoy ran buck wild around Osi Umenyiora, and figuratively over Big Blue, rushing twenty three times for 123 yards. Most disheartening, the majority of his yardage came in the second half.
Once again, the Giants got sliced and diced off the edges, and generally everything bounced to the outside. Carved and served would be a more accurate portrayal of the feast enjoyed by the Eagles running game. All containment has left the building. Sunday's effort was as undisciplined a performance as they've had on the field together. And as coach, if I am stressing anything this week in practice, it would be that.
Meanwhile, the deterioration of Corey Webster's play continues. DeSean Jackson had Webster twisted like a pretzel when he received a second quarter touchdown pass from Michael Vick. That's why Webster was no where to be found on the play. He was heading somewhere else. Nothing about that play has anything to do with Corey's hand being in a cast. For the fourth consecutive week now, Corey Webster has played a very suspect game.
My two greatest two concerns after Sunday's loss to the Eagles however, are the health and status of Kenny Phillips. His season was off to a tremendous start. The Secondary just can not withstand any more injuries. Losing Phillips, I believe would be major, major blow. And secondly, the Giants are now 0-2 within the division.
Mike.BTB
NEW YORK GIANTS FOOTBALL:
Missed It by THAT Much
WEEK FOUR FINAL:
GIANTS 17
EAGLES 19
First things first - The fact Lawrence Tynes missed what could have been the game winning field goal doesn't bother me in the slightest. He's got a good foot and is not why the Giants lost to the Eagles.
Next item - I do not mind that Kevin Gilbride and Coach Coughlin stayed ultra aggressive towards the end of Sunday night's game. There was a time (as recently as last season) when I would have ripped into the Offensive Coordinator. I guess two Super Bowls and Eli Manning have altered my thinking somewhat. Sure I would have ran the ball on second down with under 0:30 seconds left. But such as life. Let's not be hypocrites...okay? The old adage is you play for the win on the road, and for the tie at home. Could the coaches have considered a different way to matriculate the ball into field goal range? Yes, but again, I'm not concerned. Remember what they say about hindsight and apply it here.
Third on my list - I do not mind Eli's earlier interception in the end zone. Although that was perhaps one of the worse he has ever thrown. The fact is, offensively, Eli and whatever receivers on the field at any given time are the only components functioning well. With regards to Eli heroics, this is just the way this game played out. We fans can do a better job tempering ourselves when we start demanding perfection.
If Eli is indeed functioning well, let's give the Offensive Line some credit before I start a different tact. The Offensive Line has indeed provided Eli enough time to throw the ball. Eli suffered no sacks Sunday evening. They got help blocking from Martellus Bennett and Ahmad Bradshaw. But through a quarter season thus far, the group has pass protected well with or without David Diehl in the line-up.
Here is where I am concerned. First, I do not mind Aaron Brown only rushed the ball four times considering he was coming off two very productive weeks leading into Sunday. While Eli suffered no sacks Sunday evening, the O-Line created no holes to run through. The Giants rushed for a pathetic fifty seven yards. Low production out of the backfield is more than just a pattern. That concerns me. And that's why I give the way Sunday night's game ended, a pass.
Lastly, I was even more perturbed by costly holding penalties committed by the Offensive Line; i.e. - Will Beatty and Sean Locklear in particular.
If a team runs the ball well, and defends against the run well, that team will win a preponderance of their games. There in lies the reason why the Giants lost. Against the Eagles, they did neither well. Sunday night's contest was one of those very winnable games the Giants let slip by. But make no mistake, this game wasn't lost because Tynes missed the last second field goal, or Eli's INT in the end zone, or the Giants inability to run the ball. The Giants lost that game because they couldn't for the life of them stop Philadelphia's running game. All told, the Eagles gained 191 yards rushing. Michael Vick sprung free for forty nine yards on six carries. And LeSean McCoy ran buck wild around Osi Umenyiora, and figuratively over Big Blue, rushing twenty three times for 123 yards. Most disheartening, the majority of his yardage came in the second half.
Once again, the Giants got sliced and diced off the edges, and generally everything bounced to the outside. Carved and served would be a more accurate portrayal of the feast enjoyed by the Eagles running game. All containment has left the building. Sunday's effort was as undisciplined a performance as they've had on the field together. And as coach, if I am stressing anything this week in practice, it would be that.
Meanwhile, the deterioration of Corey Webster's play continues. DeSean Jackson had Webster twisted like a pretzel when he received a second quarter touchdown pass from Michael Vick. That's why Webster was no where to be found on the play. He was heading somewhere else. Nothing about that play has anything to do with Corey's hand being in a cast. For the fourth consecutive week now, Corey Webster has played a very suspect game.
My two greatest two concerns after Sunday's loss to the Eagles however, are the health and status of Kenny Phillips. His season was off to a tremendous start. The Secondary just can not withstand any more injuries. Losing Phillips, I believe would be major, major blow. And secondly, the Giants are now 0-2 within the division.
Mike.BTB
Sunday, September 30, 2012
New York Giants: Philly Showdown - I
From the desk of: DO IT FOR THE DUKE
NEW YORK GIANTS FOOTBALL: Might As Well Play This Game In A School Yard. Let's Get It On!
Uh.., yeah! Remember us? And why would you? The schedule makers won't let us play at the same time everyone else does. While we're at it, why even bother playing this game on a football field? It's Philly - might as well play this game in a school yard.
Despite all the popular talk lately, I for one do not like relying on turnovers to win games. I don't care how many times Philly has turned over the ball this season. No - instead of sniffing around for turnovers, Philly/Giants games are usually more a matter of brute force, ignorance, seeing who can deliver a bigger hit, who can withstand more pain, AND the obligatory freak occurrence. It doesn't fall short on any Giants fan to know the damnedest things happen when these teams play each other. So why plan? But I'll take the turnovers when I can get them.
Last week's win over the Panthers was nice and flashy and all.., but lets get back to basics, shall we? It is time to play football in the trenches again. Here's why I think the Giants will win Sunday evening. Big Blue's defensive line is healthy, and the Eagles offensive line is not. Michael Vick is one or two big shots away from missing time this season. Who better to get after him than the Giants? Four games into the season...it is time they do.
The Giants have had trouble when plays bounce outside. Otherwise, the Giants have stayed resilient up the middle. Linval Joseph and Rocky Bernard stabilized Tackle in Chris Canty's absence. Michael Boley and Jacquian Williams continue to play well together. If Keith Rivers can ever rejoin Mathias Kiwanuka, Boley, and Williams, what a fine linebacker unit this could be; and depth with Chase Blackburn to spare. At Safety, Antrell Rolle and Kenny Phillips have been solid. Rolle's knee should be fine. And Kenny Phillips is slowly putting together the type of season we've been waiting for. So if the defense can collectively can keep Michael Vick in the middle of the field, that would create ideal conditions for the pass rushers. That in turn minimizes the exposure of the Corners. It's all relative.
The key here is Michael Boley. As the team's corner backs disintegrate behind him, Boley's responsibility of directing traffic and setting the defense increase exponentially. At Corner, Corey Webster's hand is in a cast, and Jayron Hosely is out. Webster will still play, but then again, he's been getting burnt like toast in two of three games. Prince Amukamara and Michael Coe are still trying to get off the carpet as well.
So it falls back on Michael Boley and his unit to ensure the front seven pose major problems for Michael Vick. If the G-Men keep Vick contained inside the numbers, and make him wait for something to open up down field, the pass rush will come. If the Eagles O-Line is as banged up as advertised, the G-Men should be upon Vick quickly.
Why is this game going to come down to a field goal? The Eagles are going to defend the run a lot better than the Panthers did. Be sure of that. So look for a one week down tick in Andre Brown's performance. Ahmad Bradshaw will play. He has always bounced back well. We'll see how he bounces back this game.
As well as the Giants reconfigured Offensive Line has played these last two games, Philly's defensive front line is no joke. For Sean Locklear, this is like getting thrown into the fire. He's in, and David Diehl is out. Some will even argue the O-Line has played better in Diehl's absence. To that I say show me against the Eagles. Odds are Eli gets to talk with some of Philly's defensive players up close this Sunday evening. If recent history repeats itself, Eli might even throw an INT. He'll be going it without Hakeem Nicks. But Eli, and the rest of the available receivers should do just enough to squeeze out a close win in Philly.
Mike.BTB
NEW YORK GIANTS FOOTBALL: Might As Well Play This Game In A School Yard. Let's Get It On!
Uh.., yeah! Remember us? And why would you? The schedule makers won't let us play at the same time everyone else does. While we're at it, why even bother playing this game on a football field? It's Philly - might as well play this game in a school yard.
Despite all the popular talk lately, I for one do not like relying on turnovers to win games. I don't care how many times Philly has turned over the ball this season. No - instead of sniffing around for turnovers, Philly/Giants games are usually more a matter of brute force, ignorance, seeing who can deliver a bigger hit, who can withstand more pain, AND the obligatory freak occurrence. It doesn't fall short on any Giants fan to know the damnedest things happen when these teams play each other. So why plan? But I'll take the turnovers when I can get them.
Last week's win over the Panthers was nice and flashy and all.., but lets get back to basics, shall we? It is time to play football in the trenches again. Here's why I think the Giants will win Sunday evening. Big Blue's defensive line is healthy, and the Eagles offensive line is not. Michael Vick is one or two big shots away from missing time this season. Who better to get after him than the Giants? Four games into the season...it is time they do.
The Giants have had trouble when plays bounce outside. Otherwise, the Giants have stayed resilient up the middle. Linval Joseph and Rocky Bernard stabilized Tackle in Chris Canty's absence. Michael Boley and Jacquian Williams continue to play well together. If Keith Rivers can ever rejoin Mathias Kiwanuka, Boley, and Williams, what a fine linebacker unit this could be; and depth with Chase Blackburn to spare. At Safety, Antrell Rolle and Kenny Phillips have been solid. Rolle's knee should be fine. And Kenny Phillips is slowly putting together the type of season we've been waiting for. So if the defense can collectively can keep Michael Vick in the middle of the field, that would create ideal conditions for the pass rushers. That in turn minimizes the exposure of the Corners. It's all relative.
The key here is Michael Boley. As the team's corner backs disintegrate behind him, Boley's responsibility of directing traffic and setting the defense increase exponentially. At Corner, Corey Webster's hand is in a cast, and Jayron Hosely is out. Webster will still play, but then again, he's been getting burnt like toast in two of three games. Prince Amukamara and Michael Coe are still trying to get off the carpet as well.
So it falls back on Michael Boley and his unit to ensure the front seven pose major problems for Michael Vick. If the G-Men keep Vick contained inside the numbers, and make him wait for something to open up down field, the pass rush will come. If the Eagles O-Line is as banged up as advertised, the G-Men should be upon Vick quickly.
Why is this game going to come down to a field goal? The Eagles are going to defend the run a lot better than the Panthers did. Be sure of that. So look for a one week down tick in Andre Brown's performance. Ahmad Bradshaw will play. He has always bounced back well. We'll see how he bounces back this game.
As well as the Giants reconfigured Offensive Line has played these last two games, Philly's defensive front line is no joke. For Sean Locklear, this is like getting thrown into the fire. He's in, and David Diehl is out. Some will even argue the O-Line has played better in Diehl's absence. To that I say show me against the Eagles. Odds are Eli gets to talk with some of Philly's defensive players up close this Sunday evening. If recent history repeats itself, Eli might even throw an INT. He'll be going it without Hakeem Nicks. But Eli, and the rest of the available receivers should do just enough to squeeze out a close win in Philly.
Mike.BTB
Tuesday, September 18, 2012
New York Giants: Their Best Defense Was A Good Second Half Offense
From the desk of: DO IT FOR THE DUKE
As far as the manner in which Tampa's Head Coach Greg Schiano decides to run his team, that's fine. Just be consistent. In my book, the Bucs need to pull that college stunt all season long now to justify themselves. As far as the Giants were concerned on the play, I have but one massage for them - Assume nothing and prepare for everything. If Tampa's defense was in their stance, the Offensive Line should have been prepared. Twenty and twenty five years ago, this happened more frequently. It's really no big deal. Now as a Giants fan, what is there not to love about Coach Coughlin's response? That's is one righteous dude. And that's all I have on Schiano-Gate, for we have bigger and better things to tackle.
That was a close one. But it was a game I saw coming. Tampa almost beat the Giants the same exact way they defeated Cam Newton and the Panthers in Week One. The only difference between this game for Tampa and last week's game against Carolina was.....Eli Manning. After a miserable first quarter, and overall poor first half, Eli posted the second highest total passing yards in Giants history. He fell just s few yards short of Phil Simms' club mark. For Eli however, five hundred ten passing yards are a career best.
My top concerns on Offense revolve around continued dropped passes, David Wilson's recurring nightmare, and injuries.
Martellus Bennett, while making plays and scoring, is dropping big passes. What started in Week One, continued in Week Two. He will no doubt need to improve his receiving. However, indications Bennett and Eli will make a strong connection remain strong. Then there was the curious end-zone play designed for Will Beatty who was declared eligible on the play. Eli's pass wasn't perfect. However, his offering was too catchable for Beatty not to pull in. Were not for mishandling the ball, the play would have went for an easy touchdown.
I saved the most glaring dropped pass for last. On the Giants opening drive Dave Wilson dropped a loaf of bread placed perfectly into his basket by Eli Manning. Of the three dropped passes mentioned here, I feel this was by far the most egregious. Why? Because Martellus Bennett still gets the benefit of the doubt; because the pass to Beatty was a gimmick play; and because David Wilson is an unproven rookie whom the Giants are overly dependent on since the departures of D.J. Ware and Brandon Jacobs. And now that Ahmad Bradshaw suffered his first dent of the regular season, the Giants backfield situation and their reliance on Wilson is exacerbated.
One player's failure however, is another player's opportunity. And in the case of Andre Brown, he hit the daily double. After Ahmad Bradshaw went down in the first half with a neck injury, and with Wilson off pondering his existence somewhere on the sidelines, Andre stepped in and carried thirteen times and gained seventy one yards. He also rushed for a touchdown.
While the arrival of Andre Brown is a nice story, David Wilson devolving before our eyes is a bigger story. He is off to a most inauspicious NFL start. In his first two games as a professional, he has both fumbled and dropped an easy pass, twice occurring within the opponent's twenty yard line. He is yet to complete one full quarter of football without incident. No..., rather he is yet to complete a half-quarter without incident. That has to wear on one's confidence. And I'm sure a taskmaster like Coach Coughlin is not making his rookie existence so pleasant right about now. Where can this young man's mind set be at this moment? The Giants situation still remains. Big Blue needs David Wilson with a clear mind no later than Thursday night as Ahmad Bradshaw will be out versus the Panthers.
The MCL injury to David Diehl is also very concerning. With Will Beatty already in the game, Sean Locklear was playing more Sunday afternoon, than he did all of last year. Should Diehl miss significant time, an already thin Offensive Line will be pushed to its limits and talent. Why beat around the bush? In spite of my anxiety, they protected Eli superbly Sunday afternoon, allowing him to get off fifty one sack free attempts, and in effect helped propel Eli to pass for over five hundred yards. They also regrouped, and created just enough daylight for Andre Brown to have a fine game.
Where would the Giants be without Hakeem Nicks? And where exactly is his injured foot taking the Giants? From Monday through Saturday, fans are made to believe Hakeem's injury is the worst thing that could befall a bi-pedal creature. Then on Sundays, he hobbles to greatness. But you can't like the way he limped around after one particular tackle around his ankles. Making matters worse, Domenick Hixon will be out of Thursday's game with concussion symptoms. I just finished saying last week how happy I was to see him back too.
Chalk Week Two up to Eli and a resurgent Offensive Line effort. The Giants are 1-1 after two games. The pressure of dropping to 0-2 have been narrowly averted. All is well again. There is nothing more to see here. Go back to your farms now. Thank you for your concern. Move along.
Mike.BTB
1985 Season - Phil Simms
Holds N.Y. Giants Record For
Most Passing Yards In A Single Game; 513 Yards
NEW YORK FOOTBALL GIANTS: Sometimes The Best Defense is a Good Offense. For The Times When There Is No Defense, Giants Turn To Eli.
My Top Three Concerns On Offense:
The Game That Was - Week Two
As far as the manner in which Tampa's Head Coach Greg Schiano decides to run his team, that's fine. Just be consistent. In my book, the Bucs need to pull that college stunt all season long now to justify themselves. As far as the Giants were concerned on the play, I have but one massage for them - Assume nothing and prepare for everything. If Tampa's defense was in their stance, the Offensive Line should have been prepared. Twenty and twenty five years ago, this happened more frequently. It's really no big deal. Now as a Giants fan, what is there not to love about Coach Coughlin's response? That's is one righteous dude. And that's all I have on Schiano-Gate, for we have bigger and better things to tackle.
That was a close one. But it was a game I saw coming. Tampa almost beat the Giants the same exact way they defeated Cam Newton and the Panthers in Week One. The only difference between this game for Tampa and last week's game against Carolina was.....Eli Manning. After a miserable first quarter, and overall poor first half, Eli posted the second highest total passing yards in Giants history. He fell just s few yards short of Phil Simms' club mark. For Eli however, five hundred ten passing yards are a career best.
My top concerns on Offense revolve around continued dropped passes, David Wilson's recurring nightmare, and injuries.
Martellus Bennett, while making plays and scoring, is dropping big passes. What started in Week One, continued in Week Two. He will no doubt need to improve his receiving. However, indications Bennett and Eli will make a strong connection remain strong. Then there was the curious end-zone play designed for Will Beatty who was declared eligible on the play. Eli's pass wasn't perfect. However, his offering was too catchable for Beatty not to pull in. Were not for mishandling the ball, the play would have went for an easy touchdown.
I saved the most glaring dropped pass for last. On the Giants opening drive Dave Wilson dropped a loaf of bread placed perfectly into his basket by Eli Manning. Of the three dropped passes mentioned here, I feel this was by far the most egregious. Why? Because Martellus Bennett still gets the benefit of the doubt; because the pass to Beatty was a gimmick play; and because David Wilson is an unproven rookie whom the Giants are overly dependent on since the departures of D.J. Ware and Brandon Jacobs. And now that Ahmad Bradshaw suffered his first dent of the regular season, the Giants backfield situation and their reliance on Wilson is exacerbated.
One player's failure however, is another player's opportunity. And in the case of Andre Brown, he hit the daily double. After Ahmad Bradshaw went down in the first half with a neck injury, and with Wilson off pondering his existence somewhere on the sidelines, Andre stepped in and carried thirteen times and gained seventy one yards. He also rushed for a touchdown.
While the arrival of Andre Brown is a nice story, David Wilson devolving before our eyes is a bigger story. He is off to a most inauspicious NFL start. In his first two games as a professional, he has both fumbled and dropped an easy pass, twice occurring within the opponent's twenty yard line. He is yet to complete one full quarter of football without incident. No..., rather he is yet to complete a half-quarter without incident. That has to wear on one's confidence. And I'm sure a taskmaster like Coach Coughlin is not making his rookie existence so pleasant right about now. Where can this young man's mind set be at this moment? The Giants situation still remains. Big Blue needs David Wilson with a clear mind no later than Thursday night as Ahmad Bradshaw will be out versus the Panthers.
The MCL injury to David Diehl is also very concerning. With Will Beatty already in the game, Sean Locklear was playing more Sunday afternoon, than he did all of last year. Should Diehl miss significant time, an already thin Offensive Line will be pushed to its limits and talent. Why beat around the bush? In spite of my anxiety, they protected Eli superbly Sunday afternoon, allowing him to get off fifty one sack free attempts, and in effect helped propel Eli to pass for over five hundred yards. They also regrouped, and created just enough daylight for Andre Brown to have a fine game.
Where would the Giants be without Hakeem Nicks? And where exactly is his injured foot taking the Giants? From Monday through Saturday, fans are made to believe Hakeem's injury is the worst thing that could befall a bi-pedal creature. Then on Sundays, he hobbles to greatness. But you can't like the way he limped around after one particular tackle around his ankles. Making matters worse, Domenick Hixon will be out of Thursday's game with concussion symptoms. I just finished saying last week how happy I was to see him back too.
Chalk Week Two up to Eli and a resurgent Offensive Line effort. The Giants are 1-1 after two games. The pressure of dropping to 0-2 have been narrowly averted. All is well again. There is nothing more to see here. Go back to your farms now. Thank you for your concern. Move along.
Mike.BTB
Saturday, August 11, 2012
N.Y. Giants: On Kevin Gilbride, and an Offensive Line Preview
From the desk of: DO IT FOR THE DUKE
I give. I know when I've been defeated. Therefore, I here-by cease and desist my yearly vitriol and caustic attacks against the Giants offensive ring master. While that's not entirely true, he does deserve the benefit of the doubt from now on. Kevin Gilbride is entering his seventh season as Offensive Coordinator. And while under his directive, Big Blue's Offense launched dual Super Bowl efforts over the New England Patriots; make that Bill Belichick's Patriots.
Damn! Kevin Gilbride never left me short for subject matter. But what can I say now?
Regardless of my Bill Parcell's era philosophy and belief in Smash Mouth Football, Kevin Gilbride's implementation of the running game is no longer up for discussion. But not because of the former QB's insistence with passing the ball, and because of his history orchestrating the Run-and Shoot. But because the way the Giants traditionally run the ball is now in flux.
Not only is the Giants' All-Time rushing touchdowns leader; Brandon Jacobs; gone to San Francisco, welcome to year two of reconstructing of the Offensive Line. Last season, GM Jerry Reese decided to part ways with Shaun O'Hara and Rich Suebert. This season, Kareem McKenzie was hacked from the Giants once record-setting Offensive Line. I personally thought the seven year Giants Right Tackle was coming off one his best seasons. The anemic Giants running game experienced its most success last season rushing to the right side between McKenzie, and Chris Snee. But the Giants enjoyed even more success running outside Right Tackle; that being Kareem McKenzie. For the moment, he remains an unsigned free agent. But then again, with regards to the running game, the Giants rushed the ball dead last in Football last season. So anything is fair game at this point.
That leaves two members of the famed Offensive Line left; David Diehl, and the already mentioned, Chris Snee. David Diehl continues to get ping-ponged back and forth between the left and right sides of the line, as well as from Tackle to Guard. Which will it be this season? We'll see. The plan was to have him take Kareem McKenzie's spot on the right side. But for the moment, that remains to be seen. Entering his tenth season, he will turn thirty-two years old once the season starts. While still a very good lineman, it seems logical he will be the next player to get replaced.
Chris Snee continues to play at an All-Pro level. He turned thirty in January, so there is still a lot of football remaining in this kid. Entering his ninth season, the Giants Right Guard was perhaps the team's best run blocker last season. When the Giants needed daylight, they looked between Snee and McKenzie. Snee will now have a new partner on his right side this season.
To Chris Snee's left, will be returning Center, David Baas. I rode him hard last season. To be fair, there was an adjustment period for him, he played through a neck injury, and dealt with some minor issues. But he finished strong, and played very well in the NFC Championship Game against his former team, the San Francisco 49ers. I still feel he is undersized. But if he plays the way he did down the stretch last season, he may yet turn into a bright spot on the Line.
The biggest questions for the Giants Offensive rest on the left side. At Left Tackle, Will Beatty is supposed to finally take over. His eye injury last season necessitated David Diehl's shift to Left Tackle. So it stands to reason, Will's health this season will go a long way towards determining the Offensive Line's continuity and stability. Now that he's back, Beatty is charged with protecting Eli Manning's blind side. I'm not exactly overwhelmed with confidence he can. Will Beatty is more of a technique and finesse player. I'm concerned how well he can handle brute force and ignorance on the end. But that was the plan last year, and remains so this year. Will Beatty is no stranger to Giants fans. And he's proved to be a very capable player before, despite my reservations.
Left Guard is perhaps the largest question mark of the Offensive Line. What is certain, the position will have a new starting player. Whether Mitch Petrus wins the job, or Kevin Boothe proves best, will be determined over the pre-season. In either case, I am comfortable with the Giants' options. I especially like Mitch Petrus, who provided an instant spark in the running game last season, when David Baas went down with an injury, and the Line shifted, creating a spot for Petrus at Left Guard. That's when Kevin Boothe filled in at Center very admirably. Kevin Boothe however, is the favorite this season to win the Guard job. And that's fine with me.
Who will be backing up the forward ranks remains to be seen. Jim Cordle I'm certain will make the team. Sean Locklear is becoming an increasingly important back-up player on the left side. James Brewer returns from last season but still has much to prove. And rookie Brandon Mosely just might play his way onto the team.
As a unit, the Offensive Line returns with familiar names. There is a continuity factor that should work in the Giants favor. Good health can only make this unit better. Despite last season's rushing numbers, this unit can be very good. But after Mitch Petrus, the Giants start to suffer from a considerable lack of depth.
A greater conversation incorporating the backfield follows next.
Mike.BTB
NEW YORK GIANTS FOOTBALL:
It Is Time To Give Coach Kevin Gilbride His Due Praise.
Offensive Line Preview
I give. I know when I've been defeated. Therefore, I here-by cease and desist my yearly vitriol and caustic attacks against the Giants offensive ring master. While that's not entirely true, he does deserve the benefit of the doubt from now on. Kevin Gilbride is entering his seventh season as Offensive Coordinator. And while under his directive, Big Blue's Offense launched dual Super Bowl efforts over the New England Patriots; make that Bill Belichick's Patriots.
Damn! Kevin Gilbride never left me short for subject matter. But what can I say now?
Regardless of my Bill Parcell's era philosophy and belief in Smash Mouth Football, Kevin Gilbride's implementation of the running game is no longer up for discussion. But not because of the former QB's insistence with passing the ball, and because of his history orchestrating the Run-and Shoot. But because the way the Giants traditionally run the ball is now in flux.
Not only is the Giants' All-Time rushing touchdowns leader; Brandon Jacobs; gone to San Francisco, welcome to year two of reconstructing of the Offensive Line. Last season, GM Jerry Reese decided to part ways with Shaun O'Hara and Rich Suebert. This season, Kareem McKenzie was hacked from the Giants once record-setting Offensive Line. I personally thought the seven year Giants Right Tackle was coming off one his best seasons. The anemic Giants running game experienced its most success last season rushing to the right side between McKenzie, and Chris Snee. But the Giants enjoyed even more success running outside Right Tackle; that being Kareem McKenzie. For the moment, he remains an unsigned free agent. But then again, with regards to the running game, the Giants rushed the ball dead last in Football last season. So anything is fair game at this point.
That leaves two members of the famed Offensive Line left; David Diehl, and the already mentioned, Chris Snee. David Diehl continues to get ping-ponged back and forth between the left and right sides of the line, as well as from Tackle to Guard. Which will it be this season? We'll see. The plan was to have him take Kareem McKenzie's spot on the right side. But for the moment, that remains to be seen. Entering his tenth season, he will turn thirty-two years old once the season starts. While still a very good lineman, it seems logical he will be the next player to get replaced.
Chris Snee continues to play at an All-Pro level. He turned thirty in January, so there is still a lot of football remaining in this kid. Entering his ninth season, the Giants Right Guard was perhaps the team's best run blocker last season. When the Giants needed daylight, they looked between Snee and McKenzie. Snee will now have a new partner on his right side this season.
To Chris Snee's left, will be returning Center, David Baas. I rode him hard last season. To be fair, there was an adjustment period for him, he played through a neck injury, and dealt with some minor issues. But he finished strong, and played very well in the NFC Championship Game against his former team, the San Francisco 49ers. I still feel he is undersized. But if he plays the way he did down the stretch last season, he may yet turn into a bright spot on the Line.
The biggest questions for the Giants Offensive rest on the left side. At Left Tackle, Will Beatty is supposed to finally take over. His eye injury last season necessitated David Diehl's shift to Left Tackle. So it stands to reason, Will's health this season will go a long way towards determining the Offensive Line's continuity and stability. Now that he's back, Beatty is charged with protecting Eli Manning's blind side. I'm not exactly overwhelmed with confidence he can. Will Beatty is more of a technique and finesse player. I'm concerned how well he can handle brute force and ignorance on the end. But that was the plan last year, and remains so this year. Will Beatty is no stranger to Giants fans. And he's proved to be a very capable player before, despite my reservations.
Left Guard is perhaps the largest question mark of the Offensive Line. What is certain, the position will have a new starting player. Whether Mitch Petrus wins the job, or Kevin Boothe proves best, will be determined over the pre-season. In either case, I am comfortable with the Giants' options. I especially like Mitch Petrus, who provided an instant spark in the running game last season, when David Baas went down with an injury, and the Line shifted, creating a spot for Petrus at Left Guard. That's when Kevin Boothe filled in at Center very admirably. Kevin Boothe however, is the favorite this season to win the Guard job. And that's fine with me.
Who will be backing up the forward ranks remains to be seen. Jim Cordle I'm certain will make the team. Sean Locklear is becoming an increasingly important back-up player on the left side. James Brewer returns from last season but still has much to prove. And rookie Brandon Mosely just might play his way onto the team.
As a unit, the Offensive Line returns with familiar names. There is a continuity factor that should work in the Giants favor. Good health can only make this unit better. Despite last season's rushing numbers, this unit can be very good. But after Mitch Petrus, the Giants start to suffer from a considerable lack of depth.
A greater conversation incorporating the backfield follows next.
Mike.BTB
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)