YEAR EIGHT
FRIDAY
New York Knicks
vs.
Brooklyn Nets
FROM
FLATBUSH AVENUE
SINCE THE FIRST MOMENT SHOVELS SCOOP DIRT AT GROUNDBREAKING CEREMONIES, BROOKLYN FOR BETTER OR WORSE REMAINS ONE STEP AHEAD OF THEIR EAST RIVER RIVALS.
More better than worse ...
Kings County native and real estate developer Bruce Ratner in 2004 reveals plans to purchase the New Jersey Nets with the intent of relocating them into a new arena proposed for construction in downtown Brooklyn. On more than one occasion his vision appears dead on the drawing board. For six long years protests and seemingly endless litigation stymie any and all forward progress. A sudden contraction of the national economy further compromises Ratner's finances and development efforts.
With Ratner bogged down in court, New York Knicks owner James Dolan in 2005 is able to successfully devote his full attention and financial resources towards thwarting a more tangible threat posed by a New York Jets stadium being proposed for construction atop Manhattan's west side rail yards. However, Dolan's victory over NYC's politico and the Jets is short lived. By 2010 Bruce Ratner not only wins court approval to move forward with construction of an arena, but also secures an infusion of needed capital courtesy of new partner Mikhail Prokhorov.
On March 11, 2010, fifty-three years after the Dodgers play their last game at Ebbets Field, groundbreaking ceremonies take place for Barclays Center ironically in the same general location Walter O'Malley had once hoped to secure for his baseball club bordered by Flatbush Avenue and Atlantic Avenue. Back here in the future, Ratner's legal victory makes certain direct inner-city competition will soon be arriving at James Dolan's door step. This time there's nothing J.D. can do to prevent this from happening.
Later that summer Mikhail Prokhorov launches the first salvo in what becomes known as the Billboard Wars when he commissions a building-side mural featuring Jay-Z and himself just a few blocks away from Madison Square Garden along Eighth Avenue. James Dolan strikes back with a rather clever purchase of billboard space located within the Atlantic Yards footprint itself.
Hostilities ratchet up in February of 2011 upon outbreak of the now infamous Melo War. Carmelo Anthony makes it clear he wants out of Denver and is a handshake agreement away from authorizing a sign and trade to the New Jersey Nets. That is until Jim Dolan catches wind of it and launches himself headlong into the Carmelo Anthony trade negotiations like a charging bull through a fine china shop. Dolan tramples general manager Donnie Walsh with an utter lack of compunction, and is equally dismissive of head coach Mike D'Antoni en route to securing one of the league's perennial scoring threats. But to his great dismay the Nets are the next morning's lead story, arresting tabloid and sports radio attention away from the Knicks with a stunning overnight acquisition of well regarded point guard Deron Williams from the Utah Jazz. A squabbling media rages throughout the day debating which team executed the better deal. Because there is a point guard involved, the consensus says Nets.
With Barclays Center scheduled for opening by the 2012-2013 season, James Dolan also in 2011 orders a billion dollar renovation of Madison Square Garden.
- Question: Were it not for Barclays Center does James Dolan renovate a
his tax-shelteredbuilding that really isn't his?
Neither Carmelo Anthony or Deron Williams perform up to their team's respective satisfaction. In 2012-13, Carmelo Anthony leads the Knicks to an Atlantic Division title, but they've failed to qualify for the playoffs in the six seasons since. The Knicks average just 34.2 wins during Melo's five seasons in Manhattan, and just 33.3 wins in the five years prior to David Fizdale's arrival. Meanwhile the Nets make three straight playoff appearances in their first three seasons at Barclays. In truth their ill fated acquisition of Paul Pierce and Kevin Garnett better serve as springboards into the abyss. Suffice it to say the Melo/Williams era ends with a whimper. In 2015 the Nets buy out the remainder of Deron Williams' contract, and by 2017 the Knicks trade Carmelo Anthony to the Oklahoma City Thunder.
A new rebuilding period ensues. The Nets are first to acknowledge their organizational failures and by 2016-2017 recommit themselves to a grassroots rebuild. They hire Sean Marks as new general manager who in turn hires Kenny Atkinson as head coach. Bereft of high draft picks the new general manager and head coach strip down the team, and through organizational discipline manage to effectively and efficiently build it back up. Agreeably ahead of schedule, the Nets last season put forth a spirited and unified effort resulting in a well earned post-season appearance. If nothing else it serves to confirm Sean Marks, Kenny Atkinson, and the Nets, have gone about their business in fine manner.
The Knicks on the other hand are far slower in recognizing their blight, and perhaps more stubborn, as well. I view Sam Mills as nothing more than James Dolan's lone remaining friend in the building, and Scott Perry as a rather inconsequential league executive. This, along with the Phil Jacksons in life is why I believe the Knicks lag far behind the Nets and continue losing ground by the day. Lest we forget this is about direct competition. The Nets are the invaders, and Jim Dolan was made to defend. To date, he's tried matching them move for move. Yet somehow continues falling farther and farther behind. His front offices tried clearing cap space in order to facilitate a free agent haul a first time and came up woefully short. They retried clearing cap space this past off-season in order to facilitate yet another proposed free agent haul and again fail miserably. Unfortunately the free agent market proved shy on players motivated to shoulder 20 years of dysfunction and front office futility. Why bother when today's NBA player can easily make big money elsewhere with far less headaches.
This is precisely why Sean Marks' acquisitions of Kyrie Irving and Kevin Durant are prime examples of culture, chemistry, competence, and ultimately competitiveness, coming together under the same roof.
It's true ...
But this has never been about the Knicks. The Nets are foolish to think they can steal fans away from the establishment. Barclays Center attendance bears that out. Since day one this has always been about winning over the 2.7 million denizens of Brooklyn. James Dolan has always benefited from playing in a midtown arena where tourists ensure a sellout every day and night no matter what. In that respect he is well shielded. Anywhere else and Dolan's gate receipts would more accurately reflect true fan ire (same holds true for the Rangers). Brooklyn is a different kinda cat. Therefore the real test lay ahead. Last season's organic rise to competitiveness was an endearing experience bringing club and fan closer together than at any other time over the previous six seasons. That, along with the off-season acquisitions of Kyrie Irvin and Kevin Durant make this easily the most anticipated season in Brooklyn's NBA history. Whether that translates at the gate remains to be seen. So far, the pre-season buzz in Kings County is palpable.
But there is no rivalry; not yet; or at least not until the Knicks step up their game. We're entering Year Eight with no signs of improvement across the river. A true rivalry would be nice. In the meantime, bet on Brooklyn.
OPENING NIGHT
WEDNESDAY
Timberwolves
vs.
Nets
FROM
BARCLAYS CENTER
No comments:
Post a Comment
Say what you feel. The worse comment you can make is the one you do not make.